
IS IMAM MAHDI HIDING IN A CELLAR IN SAMARRA?
A source-based study showing the mainstream Twelver belief about Imam al-Mahdi's occultation and refuting the claim that he is hiding in a cellar in Samarra.
In-depth articles and research on Shia Islam, history, theology, and contemporary issues.

A source-based study showing the mainstream Twelver belief about Imam al-Mahdi's occultation and refuting the claim that he is hiding in a cellar in Samarra.

A source-based study of the Twelve Imams, the Qur'anic pattern of twelve, the authentic Sunni hadith of twelve caliphs, and the Twelver Shia identification.

A source-based comparison of Sunni and Imami Shia views on the Prophet's literacy, examining Qur'an 29:48, hadith evidence and the meaning of "ummi."

A source-based analysis of the Sunni report about Imam Ali and Uthman, showing it denies personal hostility but not their serious religious disagreements.

A source-based study examining Abdullah ibn Saba, showing that Shia Imams condemned him and exposing the lack of evidence that he founded Shiism.

A source-based study of Khutbah al-Qasi'ah, explaining the Shia doctrine of lutf and showing why Imam Ali's sermon does not refute divine grace.

A source-based study showing Shia hadith does not contradict itself on wilayah, but distinguishes earlier revelation, explanation and Ghadir's final message

A source-based study of Hadith al-Dar, examining its chains, Sunni scholarly views and the family gathering linked to Qur'an 26:214 and Imam Ali.

A source-based study of Shaykh al-Mufid's writings, explaining Islam, iman and kufr while refuting claims that he contradicted himself about Umar.

A source-based study of Imam Ali's funeral prayer, proving five takbirs have Prophetic roots and exposing errors in claims against Shia Janazah practice.

A source-based analysis showing shared names and kunyahs among Ahl al-Bayt do not prove love, political approval or endorsement of specific figures.

A hadith-critical study of the report that Imam Ali sent salat upon Umar, examining its chain, wording, Sunni criticism and the distinction from ritual salat.