Was Aisha Really 9 When Married to Prophet S.A.W.W?
Sep 19, 2026ShiaRef4 min read
Sunni sources and scholars on ʿĀʾishah’s age at marriage, including the historical case for an age of 17–19.
Refutations
Browse published research and reflections in this selected topic.
Yanbuʿ Was Not Fadak
Aug 20, 2026ShiaRef4 min read
A critical Twelver Shia refutation of the claim that Umar’s grant of Yanbuʿ to Imam Ali compensated for Fadak, using Qur’an, Sunni and Shia sources to examine owners
Qur’an 13:7 — The Prophet Is the Warner and ʿAlī Is the Guide
Aug 3, 2026ShiaRef4 min read
Sunni sources contain ṣaḥīḥ-level evidence that the guide is a Hāshimī man; Sunni scholars identify that Hāshimī guide as ʿAlī; and Shia ṣaḥīḥ narrations confirms.
Aisha Was Not Nine: The Established Shia Position
Jul 22, 2026ShiaRef4 min read
Explore the established Shia position on Aisha's age through early Imami sources, leading Shia scholars, and historical evidence.
Was Aisha Nine or Married Before the Prophet?
Jul 22, 2026ShiaRef4 min read
A study of Sunni evidence on Aisha's age and reports of her marriage before the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ.
Did Imam Husayn Recognize Yazid as Amir al-Mu’minin?
Jul 22, 2026ShiaRef4 min read
A critical review of the Tabari report claiming Imam Husayn accepted Yazid, examining its broken chain, Shia sources, and the eyewitness denial.
Is the City of Knowledge Hadith Fabricated?
Jul 21, 2026ShiaRef4 min read
A source-based analysis of the "City of Knowledge" hadith, examining Sunni rijal, narrator criticism, corroborating routes, and why many Sunni scholars rejected call
Was Ghadir Khumm Only About Friendship?
Jul 21, 2026ShiaRef4 min read
A source-based study of Hadith al-Ghadir examining its authentic Sunni narrations, the meaning of mawla, the Yemen context and Imam Ali's post-Prophetic wilayah.
Did the Prophet ﷺ Condemn Banu Umayyah?
Jul 21, 2026ShiaRef4 min read
A source-based analysis of authentic and Hasan Sunni reports concerning Banu Umayyah, Banu Marwan and al-Hakam, answering claims that such evidence does not exist.
IS IMAM MAHDI HIDING IN A CELLAR IN SAMARRA?
Jul 21, 2026ShiaRef4 min read
A source-based study showing the mainstream Twelver belief about Imam al-Mahdi's occultation and refuting the claim that he is hiding in a cellar in Samarra.
Who Are the Ithna 'Ashariyyah (Twelvers)?
Jul 21, 2026ShiaRef4 min read
A source-based study of the Twelve Imams, the Qur'anic pattern of twelve, the authentic Sunni hadith of twelve caliphs, and the Twelver Shia identification.
Imam Ali and Uthman: "Nothing Except Goodness"?
Jul 21, 2026ShiaRef4 min read
A source-based analysis of the Sunni report about Imam Ali and Uthman, showing it denies personal hostility but not their serious religious disagreements.